We should oppose FOCA & why PP supports it

To state it clearly, I do not look to temper the final FOCA law with mollifying language. I hope to defeat the bill in its entirety and stop all of the administrative changes in law as proposed. It’s bad law based on bad science and the flawed social viewpoint of a far left micro-minority masquerading as “middle of the road.”

First reason. There are specific good laws and their subsequent clarifying court cases that restrict abortions based on Roe. FOCA would invalidate them. Sandra Day OConnor – who is somewhat left of what you’d call “moderate” – was the majority author of one of these cases: Planned Parenthood v Casey in 1992. Justice Ginsberg’s strident dissenting opinion in PP v Casey – considering the source – proves that this is good law. PP holds up Ginsberg’s dissent with near-religious fervor. Another is the Hyde-Weldon Amendment upheld by the 9th District in San Francisco. The pro-abortion side chose that case in that venue because of the liberal leanings of that court. Both of these and many others are current good law that FOCA would invalidate.

Second. There is a problem with ignoring PP. Their advocacy of a viewpoint approaches mono-mania. Their presence on the podium when HRC (Hillary Rodham Clinton) introduced the FOCA bill gives them the appearance of standing in the debate. There is a tendency of activist judges to read into the “intent” of an author. HRC is bad enough but what if SCOTUS quotes a PP action paper as HRC’s intent in the legislation!?

Third, FOCA has been implemented on a smaller scale and doesn’t work. Abortions increase where it’s the state law. See the information on Maryland’s experience. Federal FOCA would eliminate what restrictions there are on state FOCA laws and would cause more abortions.

Finally, government = healthcare if this administration gets its way, so FOCA would be government intervening in healthcare decisions. Doctors more than ever are paid by the state. Services are more and more provided by public entities. This civil statute with its unclear definitions is a threat of a law suit to every county health department, public hospital, doctor’s office, pharmacy, insurance company and employer. So those entities would choose to comply to avoid having to hire a lawyer. (Though organizations like the becketfund.org or the Life Legal Defense Foundation lldf.org would help them). If a private businessman chooses not to include in his health insurance for his employees the morning after pill or late term abortions then FOCA will allow a lawsuit.

FOCA is a clear path to expanding abortions. It must be resisted for all of these reasons.

this in response to comments at change.gov
Go to comment

Advertisements

4 Responses to We should oppose FOCA & why PP supports it

  1. Laura says:

    Actually, I’m still capable of childbearing. So – since you didn’t have the courage to use a real name or a real email address, where does that put you on the pecking order? Hmmmm????

    Moreover, when does a fully functioning uterus influence one’s moral judgment? Matt doesn’t possess a uterus but I can promise you his input on this matter is every bit as legitimate as mine.

  2. Matt says:

    Does Mr. Anonymous have any children?

  3. Matt says:

    Mr. Anonymous, I have to ask. Is your rude comment about women who are past child-bearing related somehow to a judgment that they cannot understand a pregnant woman’s plight and so should recuse themselves? If that’s so please see – and react with horror – that most of the employees of Planned Parenthood in these videos are “past child-bearing age.” They’re grandmothers or perhaps should be. What is motivating them to help girls – underage girls – to kill their babies?
    http://liveactionfilms.org/

  4. Laura says:

    We had to delete Mr. Anonymous’ comments. His website has pornographic materials on it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: